McNulty's    (631) 474-3543

  • Home
  • What's Sweet At McNulty's
  • Flavor Board
  • Our Menu
  • Cakes
  • Curbside Pickup
  • Parties
  • Gift Certificates
  • Contact Us

Ice Cream Treats

Something to Delight Everyone


  • Cakes
  • Flavor Board


  • Cones
  • Dishes
  • Quarts & Pints
  • Kids Corner
  • Sundae Specialities
  • Refreshing Cold Beverage Desserts
  • Ice Cream Sandwiches


    • Cones
    Regular
    $3.99
    2 Scoops
    Large
    $4.85
    3 Scoops
    Waffle Cones
    $5.75
    3 Super Sized Scoops
    Magic Shell Dip
    $.80
    Chocolate or Peanut Butter

    Dishes
    Small
    $3.99
    2 Scoops
    Medium
    $4.99
    3 Scoops
    Large
    $5.99
    5 Scoops
    Waffle Bowl
    $5.75
    3 Super Sized Scoops

    Quarts & Pints To Go
    Quarts To Go
    $8.50
    Comes with one free topping on the side
    Pints To Go
    $6.50
    Comes with one free topping on the side

    Kids Corner
    Jimmy Junior Sundae
    $3.75
    1 scoop, 1 topping, whipped cream, sprinkles, and a cherry
    Dinosaur Sundae
    $3.75
    Mint Chunk or Vanilla ice cream. Hot Fudge topping, whipped cream, sprinkles and a cherry
    Cinderella Sundae
    $3.75
    1 scoop Strawberry or Vanilla ice cream. Strawberry topping, whipped cream, rainbow sprinkles, and a cherry
    Baseball Hat Sundae
    $5.75
    1 scoop ice cream, 1 topping, whipped cream, and a cherry
    Ann Marie's Angel Sundae
    $3.75
    Twist Ice Cream, Chocolate Syrup, Whipped Cream, Chocolate Sprinkles, Salted with a Chocolate
    Matty's M&M Madness
    $3.75
    Vanilla soft Ice Cream, lots and lots of mini M&M's, Whipped Cream, and more M&M's
    James' Carmel Creation
    $3.75
    Vanilla soft Ice Cream lots of Caramel, Chocolate Chips, and Whipped Cream topped with a Caramel Candy
    The Car Sundae Hot Rod
    $5.75
    Pick your Ice Cream and Topping, top it off with Whipped Cream, Sprinkles, and a Cherry

    Sundae Specialities
    Regular = 3 Scoops
    Large = 5 Scoops

    Reg 


    Large
    Mom Mc Nulty's Traditional Style
    $5.50
    $6.75
    Your choice of Ice Cream, Topping, Whipped Cream, Sprinkles, and a Cherry
    The Miller Place CMP
    $5.99
    $6.99
    Your choice of Ice Cream, topped with Chocolate Syrup, Marshmallow, Peanuts, lots of Whipped Cream, Sprinkles, and a Cherry
    Peanut Butter Lover's Delight
    $5.99
    $6.99
    Your choice of Ice Cream, Peanut Butter Topping, Reese's Pieces, Peanut Butter Cups, Whipped Cream, Sprinkles, and a Cherry
    The Long Islander
    $5.99
    $6.99
    Creamy soft Vanilla Ice Cream with layered toppings of Butterfingers, Chocolate Chips, and Hot Fudge topped with Whipped Cream, Sprinkles, and a Cherry
    Strawberry Shortcake
    $5.99
    $6.99
    Vanilla Ice Cream, Strawberry Topping, Whipped Cream, lots of Vanilla Crunch, and a Cherry
    Colosso Sundae
    $6.99
    3 Ice Creams, 3 Toppings, Whipped Cream, Sprinkles, and a Cherry served in our Waffle Bowl
    Hot Fudge Brownie Sundae
    $6.50
    1 Super Scoop, Hot Fudge, Whipped Cream, Walnuts, and a Cherry
    Banana Boat
    $6.99
    3 Ice Creams, 3 Toppings, fresh Banana, Whipped Cream, Sprinkles, and a Cherry
    The Titanic
    $6.99
    Our Banana Boat upside down
    Billy's Super Sized Sundae
    $9.99
    6 Ice Creams, 4 Toppings, lots of Whipped Cream, Sprinkles, and a Cherry (a quart sized Sundae)

    Refreshing Cold Beverage Desserts
    Creamy Milk Shake
    $4.99
    Choose your Flavor, made thick and rich
    Milk Shake Float
    $6.50
    Creamy Shake with a large scoop of Ice Cream added
    Malted Milk Shake
    $5.29
    Choose your Flavor and add old fashioned Malted Milk made to perfection
    Ice Cream Soda
    $5.50
    Vanilla, Chocolate or Strawberry Soda, your choice of Ice Cream, Whipped Cream, Sprinkles, and a Cherry
    Brooklyn Egg Cream
    $1.85
    Coke Float
    $5.50

    Ice Cream Sandwiches
    6 Ice Cream Sandwiches
    $9.00
    Six Ice Cream Sandwiches, either Vanilla, Chocolate or Twist


    * Prices subject to change.  All orders subject to sales tax.

    McNulty's Ice Cream Parlor


    • Facebook

    153 N. Country Road
    Miller Place, NY 11764
      (631) 474-3543

    • © McNulty's Ice Cream Parlor 2022