McNulty's    (631) 474-3543

  • Home
  • What's Sweet At McNulty's
  • Flavor Board
  • Our Menu
  • Cakes
  • Curbside Pickup
  • Parties
  • Gift Certificates
  • Contact Us

CAKE PRICES AND SIZES


REGULAR CAKES

  • 6" (Serves 4-6) $21.95
  • 7" (Serves 8-10) $25.95
  • 8" (Serves 10-12) $27.95
  • 9" (Serves 12-15) $31.95
  • 10" (Serves 20-22) $34.95
  • 1/4 Sheet (Serves 20-25) $38.95
  • Square (Serves 25-30) $41.95
  • 1/2 Sheet $53.95

BANANA SPLIT CAKES

  • 6" $39.95
  • 8" $41.95
  • 10" $44.95
  • Square $52.95
  • 1/4 Sheet $50.95
  • 1/2 Sheet $65.95

ELMO & COOKIE MONSTER

  • 8" $36.95
  • 10" $42.95

DECORS

  • BANANA SPLIT DECOR $8.00 AND UP
  • WAFERS $17.95
  • PLASTIC SHEETS $17.95
  • BROWNIE PIZZA (Serves 8-10) $23.95
  • LOGS (Serves 8) $22.95
  • FOOTBALL (Serves 10) $23.95
  • 1/2 Sheet $53.95

ALL REGULAR CAKES STANDARD VANILLA & CHOCOLATE WITH CRUNCH

  • CHANGE OF FLAVORS
  • TWO FLAVORS $9.00
  • ONE FLAVOR $6.00
  • CHANGE OF FILLING $5.00
  • ADDITIONAL FILLING $4.50

  • Please allow one to two days for speciality flavor requests

McNulty's Ice Cream Parlor


  • Facebook

153 N. Country Road
Miller Place, NY 11764
  (631) 474-3543

  • © McNulty's Ice Cream Parlor 2021